If you live in Park Slope, Bay Ridge, or Bushwick and you’ve been putting off writing a will, you’re not alone. Most people aren’t sure what actually makes a will “count” under New York law. Here are the questions we hear most often from Brooklyn families.
What does New York actually require for a will to be valid?
Under New York’s Estates, Powers and Trusts Law (EPTL) §3-2.1, a will must meet several formalities. You must be at least 18 and of sound mind. The will must be in writing and signed by you (the testator) at the end of the document. You must sign, or acknowledge your earlier signature, in front of at least two witnesses. And those witnesses must sign within a 30-day window of each other. Miss one of these steps and a Kings County Surrogate’s Court judge may refuse to admit the will.
Do I need witnesses, and who can they be?
Yes—two witnesses are mandatory in New York. They should be adults who are not beneficiaries under the will. While New York doesn’t automatically void a gift to a witness, naming a disinterested witness avoids a fight later. Think of a neighbor, a coworker, or a friend from your block—not the niece you’re leaving the apartment to.
Does my will have to be notarized?
This trips up a lot of Brooklyn residents. New York does not require notarization for a will to be valid. What attorneys typically add is a “self-proving affidavit,” which the witnesses sign before a notary. It doesn’t change validity—it just lets the Surrogate’s Court accept the will later without tracking down your witnesses, who may have moved out of the borough years from now.
Can I just write my will by hand?
For most people in Kings County, no. New York recognizes handwritten (holographic) and oral (nuncupative) wills only in narrow situations, mainly for active-duty military members and mariners at sea. A handwritten note left in your Crown Heights apartment will almost certainly not be honored. Stick to the formal signing-and-witnessing process.
What should I actually put in the will?
Name an executor you trust to handle the Surrogate’s Court process. Identify your beneficiaries clearly. If you have minor children, name a guardian—this is often the single most important reason young Brooklyn parents finally sit down to write one. Be specific about property like a co-op share, a brownstone, or a family business, since vague language causes disputes.
How do I keep my will from being challenged?
Challenges usually claim lack of capacity or undue influence. Signing with disinterested witnesses, using a self-proving affidavit, and keeping the original in a safe place all help. Don’t store the only signed copy somewhere your family can’t find it—if the original can’t be located after death, New York presumes you revoked it.
A note on getting it right
The rules in EPTL §3-2.1 are technical, and small mistakes can undo your entire plan. Because every family and estate is different, this overview isn’t legal advice. Before you sign anything, talk with a New York attorney who handles Surrogate’s Court matters in Brooklyn so your wishes are honored exactly as you intend.
Have a question about your estate?
Talk it through with Russel Morgan — free 30-minute consult.